Scientific Foundations (18th–19th Centuries)

 

The underlying principles came from refrigeration research:

​

• In 1748, William Cullen demonstrated artificial refrigeration in Scotland by using a pump to create a partial vacuum over diethyl ether, causing it to boil and absorb heat from the surroundings (producing ice).

​​

• In 1834, Jacob Perkins built the first practical vapor-compression refrigeration system (“ice machine”).

​​

• In 1852, Lord Kelvin (William Thomson) articulated the thermodynamic basis of the heat pump: using mechanical energy to move heat from a colder place to a warmer one.

​​

• In the mid-1850s (around 1855–1857), Austrian engineer Peter von Rittinger built what is widely regarded as the first practical heat pump, recovering latent heat from water vapor to evaporate brine in salt works.

 

These ideas remained largely theoretical or industrial for decades.

​

 

Early Patents, Prototypes, and European Pioneering Systems (1920s–1940s)

 

• 1927–1928: T.G.N. Haldane patented a vapor-compression heat pump system for both heating and cooling in Scotland.

​​

• 1937: Gilbert Wilkes and Frank M. Reed received the first U.S. patent specifically for a heat pump water heater (US 2,095,017, filed 1935). The design featured an integrated storage tank, motor-driven compressor, evaporator, immersed condenser coil, and supplemental electric resistance elements—strikingly similar in concept to many modern integrated HPWHs.

​

Europe saw earlier practical large-scale applications, especially in Switzerland, which lacked domestic fossil fuels but had abundant hydroelectric power and faced coal shortages before and during World War II. From the late 1930s to the mid-1950s, companies such as Escher Wyss, Sulzer, and Brown Boveri installed dozens of heat pumps (roughly 35–60 systems) for space heating and domestic hot water, drawing heat from lake, river, or groundwater or waste heat. A landmark installation was the 1937/38 Escher Wyss system for Zurich City Hall (using Limmat river water), which provided heating (and later cooling capability) and operated for decades (until around 2001). Similar systems appeared for swimming pools and other uses. In the UK, John Sumner installed a notable large water-source heat pump system in Norwich in 1945. Robert C. Webber is often credited with developing an early ground-source heat pump around the same period after observing waste heat from a freezer.

​

 

First Commercialization Attempts (1950s)

 

The early 1950s brought the first mass-market residential HPWHs in the United States, credited to Hotpoint (later part of GE) and the Harvey-Whipple Company. Utility field tests around 1949–1951 demonstrated promising coefficients of performance (COP) of 3–4. Early interest was strong in the dairy industry, where simultaneous needs for refrigeration/cooling and hot water made heat recovery attractive.

​

However, declining electricity prices and cheap coal/gas alternatives limited commercial success. Development largely stalled by the late 1950s/early 1960s.

​

 

Energy Crises, Dairy Success, and Boom-Bust Cycles (1970s–2000s)

 

The 1970s oil crises and rising energy costs revived interest. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA), and utilities funded prototypes and field tests (including roughly 100 units tested by utilities).

​

A standout commercial success was Dairy Equipment Corporation (DEC International, later Therma-Stor). Starting in the late 1970s, it sold heat-recovery units heavily into the dairy market (over 20,000 units by the mid-1980s). Residential models introduced around 1980 achieved COPs of 3.1–3.5 and cut water-heating costs by about 70%.

 

Ventilating HPWH prototypes also appeared. Other players (including E-Tech/Crispaire) offered residential units from the late 1970s. Peak activity saw up to 17 manufacturers and roughly 11,000 annual U.S. sales. Commercial systems also expanded—for example, Hawaiian Electric collaborated with Westinghouse in the late 1970s–1980s to adapt industrial “Templifier” units for potable water heating in hotels, apartments, and similar buildings (hundreds installed by the 1990s with strong paybacks, often using waste heat from cooling towers). In Australia, University of Melbourne research (led by William Charters in the mid-1970s) led to commercial Quantum HPWHs (via Siddons) in the mid-1980s.

​

The market then collapsed. By the late 1980s–1990s, manufacturer numbers fell sharply, market share dropped to around 0.2%, and sales declined to roughly 2,000 units per year. Problems included reliability and service issues, high upfront costs, low consumer awareness, and softer energy prices. Many major players exited. Late-1990s/early-2000s efforts (such as the “Watter$aver” integrated unit developed with support involving ORNL/Arthur D. Little and others) showed mixed field results and limited lasting market impact. Some CO₂ refrigerant R&D occurred but did not commercialize widely in the US at the time.

​

 

Japanese Breakthrough: Eco Cute (Late 1990s–Present)

 

Japan achieved a major leap. After earlier fluorocarbon-based heat pump water heater research in the 1980s–1990s (including through the Super Heat Pump project involving CRIEPI), the Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry (CRIEPI), Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO), and Denso collaborated from the late 1990s on a CO₂ (R744) refrigerant system. CO₂’s transcritical cycle properties enable efficient high-temperature water heating (up to ~90°C).

​

The world’s first commercial residential CO₂ HPWH launched in May 2001 under the “Eco Cute” brand. Split-system designs became standard. Government subsidies, efficiency standards, manufacturer competition, and environmental benefits drove rapid adoption. Cumulative shipments exceeded 1 million by around 2007, several million by the mid-2010s, and 10 million by early 2025. Eco Cute systems demonstrated high real-world efficiency and helped establish heat pump water heating as mainstream technology in Japan and parts of Asia.

​

 

Modern Revival and Mainstream Growth (2009–Present)

 

In the US, the 2009 ENERGY STAR certification for HPWHs (requiring Energy Factor ≥2.0 and other criteria) marked a turning point. Sales rose sharply (from about 2,000 units in 2006 to 14,600 in 2009; 23 models certified by 2010).

 

GE’s GeoSpring (developed with Oak Ridge National Laboratory support via CRADA) and Rheem were early leaders; A.O. Smith and others followed. Efficiency, reliability, noise, and controls improved substantially.

​

Growth continued through the 2010s, supported by the 2015 National Appliance Energy Conservation Act amendments, the founding of the Advanced Water Heating Initiative (AWHI) in 2019, and Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) Advanced Water Heating Specifications (which expanded to cover split systems, 120 V units, and commercial/multifamily applications). Shipments roughly doubled in periods during the late 2010s and reached around 190,000 units in 2023 (about 3.9% of the US electric water heater market, with strong year-over-year growth).

​

Key modern advances include:

 

• Higher Uniform Energy Factors (often 3+x).

​​

• 120-volt plug-in models (easier retrofits without electrical panel upgrades, emerging more widely around 2022).

​​

• Split systems (heat pump outdoor unit + indoor tank) for space constraints, colder climates, or quieter indoor operation; these are becoming more available in North America after long dominance in Asia.

​​

• Variable-speed compressors, smarter controls, hybrid resistance backup modes, demand-response/load-shifting capability, and use of the tank as thermal storage (“thermal battery”).

​​

• Progress on lower-GWP refrigerants (including continued CO₂ options) and combination systems that handle both space conditioning and domestic hot water.

​​

• Policy tailwinds: local “Zero-NOx” rules phasing out combustion water heaters in some areas and 2024 DOE standards that will effectively require HPWH-level efficiency for most residential electric storage water heaters larger than 35 gallons starting around 2029.

​​

 

Overall Evolutionary Themes

 

Technically, designs evolved from early immersed-coil integrated units and simple heat-recovery add-ons, through improved heat exchangers and controls, to today’s high-efficiency integrated or split systems with advanced refrigerants, variable capacity, and grid-interactive features. Market dynamics showed repeated cycles tightly linked to energy prices and reliability until sustained policy support (standards, incentives, decarbonization goals) and product maturation after 2009 created more durable momentum. Europe demonstrated early practical success in larger systems; the US experienced pronounced boom-bust patterns until recently; Japan led volume deployment of efficient residential high-temperature systems with natural refrigerants.

​

HPWHs have moved from niche experimental devices to a core efficiency and electrification technology, offering energy savings, dehumidification/cooling benefits in many installations, and emerging roles in demand flexibility. Adoption continues to accelerate as costs fall, products improve, and regulations favor them.